NYC Pied-à-Terre Tax Explained: What Second Home Owners Need to Know

Owning a second home in New York City does not automatically mean you owe the new Pied-à-Terre Tax. However, certain owners of high-value residential properties may now face an additional annual tax known as the Non-Primary Residence Surcharge. Understanding whether this applies to you starts with three basic questions:

• ◆What type of property do you own?
• ◆What is the property's Department of Finance market value?
• ◆Is the property being used as someone's primary residence?

The surcharge generally applies to certain one-, two-, and three-family homes, condominiums, and cooperative apartments that meet specific value thresholds and are not used as a primary residence. Larger residential buildings with four or more units generally are not subject to this surcharge. The rules are not based simply on whether a property is considered a "second home"—how the property is actually used is an important factor.

Consider this example:

John lives in Florida and owns a condominium in Manhattan. The New York City Department of Finance determines the apartment's market value to be $2 million. John visits the apartment a few weekends each year but leaves it vacant the rest of the time. Because the apartment is not being used as anyone's primary residence and no exemption applies, John may be subject to the surcharge.

For a condominium with a Department of Finance market value of $2 million, the surcharge rate is 4%. John's estimated annual surcharge would be:

Now change one fact. Instead of leaving the apartment vacant, John rents the condominium to a tenant who uses it as their primary residence. In that situation, the property may qualify for an exemption, and the additional surcharge would generally not apply.

The law provides several exemptions that may prevent the surcharge from applying. A property may qualify for an exemption if it is the primary residence of the owner, a tenant or subtenant, an immediate family member of the owner, or an individual who lives in the property as their primary residence and owns more than half of the company or entity that owns the property. Certain qualifying trust beneficiaries may also qualify for an exemption.

Whether the surcharge applies is not determined solely by the value of the property. The property's classification, how it is occupied, and whether an exemption applies all play a role in determining whether the additional tax is owed.

Questions about your property's exposure?

Every situation is different. Let's look at your specific circumstances.